Yes, Exactly
From Robert Bidnotto, echoing thoughts I had here and also here, but he writes much more eloquently:
Okay, I have had it.
Not a damned thing distinguishes the Republicans from the Democrats
anymore...not a damned thing. "No Child Left Behind" in essence, and
unconstitutionally, federalized education. The GOP-engineered federal
prescription drug subsidy program for seniors was another huge and
costly step toward total socialized medicine. The Administration's
response to recent natural disasters -- here and abroad -- establishes
the premise of federalizing all local emergencies globally, and reducing the U.S. military into becoming the logistics wing of the International Red Cross.And so on, and so on....
To the Left, government should whip individuals into collective
lockstep regarding its PC-egalitarian agenda on such issues as smoking,
diets, guns, cars, nature-worship, land use, political speech and
rhetoric, equality of income and "access" to things that don't belong
to you, drafting kids for "national service," using schools to push PC
propaganda, etc.To the Right, government should whip individuals into collective
lockstep regarding its traditional moral agenda, including abortion,
sex, Darwin, cultural speech and rhetoric, marriage, national
demographic purity, drafting kids for military service, using schools
to push religious values, etc.Neither side wants a government of limited powers, and
rejects the initiation of force against others. Neither side respects
individual rights, and rejects using the "fearful" power of government
to compel the independent individual to toe its party line. Neither
side recognizes property rights, and rejects the redistributionist
welfare state.More fundamentally, neither side rejects the cannibalistic "morality" of sacrificing the individual to the group.
Left and Right both agree that the individual is their private
plaything, a sacrificial lamb for their respective pet causes. The only
thing that they really disagree about is which individuals they are
going to sacrifice, for whose benefit, and in the name of what cause.
Doug:
A couple of weeks ago, my 80 year old mother asked me how my libertarian thinking differs from the usual conservatives and liberals. After several attempts, the answer that brought an "Aha!" from her was:
Conservatives want government to make everybody behave like conservatives.
Liberals want government to make everybody behave like liberals.
Libertarians want conservatives to be free to behave like conservatives and liberals to be free to behave like liberals.
November 11, 2005, 12:25 pm